American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance Expert Unbiased Review 2024

This guide “American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance” explains pricing, availability, pros and cons, comparisons with other insurers, customer service, Click Here

Choosing between American Family Insurance and Progressive Car Insurance can be challenging. Both companies offer a range of coverage options, discount programs, and innovative tools. This detailed comparison will help you understand the differences and similarities between American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance.

Table of Contents

American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance Pricing and Availability

American Family Insurance Pricing and Availability

American Family Insurance provides competitive pricing that varies based on factors such as driving history, location, and vehicle type. The average annual premium for full coverage through American Family Insurance is around $1,512. American Family is available in 19 states, primarily in the Midwest and Pacific Northwest.

Progressive Car Insurance Pricing and Availability

Progressive is known for its competitive pricing and extensive discount opportunities. The average annual premium for full coverage with Progressive is approximately $1,509. Progressive is available in all 50 states, making it one of the most widely accessible car insurance providers in the United States.

Pricing Comparison Table

CompanyAverage Annual Premium (Full Coverage)Availability
American Family$1,51219 states
Progressive$1,509All 50 states

Coverage Options in American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance

American Family Insurance Coverage Options

American Family Insurance offers a comprehensive range of coverage options, including:

  • Liability
  • Collision
  • Comprehensive
  • Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist
  • Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
  • Medical Payments
  • Roadside Assistance
  • Rental Car Reimbursement
  • Gap Insurance
  • Accident Forgiveness
  • Diminishing Deductible

Progressive Car Insurance Coverage Options

Progressive provides a wide array of coverage options, including:

  • Liability
  • Collision
  • Comprehensive
  • Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist
  • Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
  • Medical Payments
  • Roadside Assistance
  • Rental Car Reimbursement
  • Gap Insurance
  • Custom Parts and Equipment Value
  • Rideshare Coverage

Coverage Comparison Table

Coverage TypeAmerican FamilyProgressive
LiabilityYesYes
CollisionYesYes
ComprehensiveYesYes
Uninsured/Underinsured MotoristYesYes
Personal Injury Protection (PIP)YesYes
Medical PaymentsYesYes
Roadside AssistanceYesYes
Rental Car ReimbursementYesYes
Gap InsuranceYesYes
Accident ForgivenessYesNo
Diminishing DeductibleYesYes
Custom Parts and EquipmentNoYes
Rideshare CoverageNoYes

Discount Programs of American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance

American Family Insurance Discount Programs

American Family Insurance offers a variety of discounts, such as:

  • Multi-Policy Discount
  • Multi-Vehicle Discount
  • Good Student Discount
  • Safe Driver Discount
  • Anti-Theft Device Discount
  • Accident-Free Discount
  • Defensive Driving Discount
  • Paperless Documents Discount
  • Early Bird Discount
  • Generational Discount
  • Loyalty Discount

Progressive Car Insurance Discount Programs

Progressive is well-known for its numerous discount opportunities, including:

  • Multi-Policy Discount
  • Multi-Vehicle Discount
  • Good Student Discount
  • Safe Driver Discount
  • Anti-Theft Device Discount
  • Homeowner Discount
  • Snapshot Discount
  • Pay-in-Full Discount
  • Continuous Insurance Discount
  • Online Quote Discount
  • Paperless Documents Discount
  • Sign Online Discount

Discount Comparison Table

Discount TypeAmerican FamilyProgressive
Multi-PolicyYesYes
Multi-VehicleYesYes
Good StudentYesYes
Safe DriverYesYes
Anti-Theft DeviceYesYes
Accident-FreeYesNo
Defensive DrivingYesNo
Paperless DocumentsYesYes
Early BirdYesNo
GenerationalYesNo
LoyaltyYesNo
HomeownerNoYes
SnapshotNoYes
Pay-in-FullNoYes
Continuous InsuranceNoYes
Online QuoteNoYes
Sign OnlineNoYes

American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance Customer Service Innovations

American Family Insurance Customer Service Innovations

American Family Insurance is praised for its customer service and offers a range of digital tools to enhance the customer experience. Their MyAmFam app allows policyholders to manage their policies, pay bills, and file claims. American Family also provides 24/7 customer support through its helpline.

Progressive Car Insurance Customer Service Innovations

Progressive excels in customer service innovation, offering a highly rated mobile app that provides policy management, claims filing, and access to roadside assistance. Progressive also offers the “Name Your Price” tool, allowing customers to find coverage options that fit their budget. Their customer service is available 24/7 via phone and online chat.

Customer Service Comparison Table

AspectAmerican FamilyProgressive
Mobile AppYesYes
Online PortalYesYes
24/7 Customer SupportYesYes
Personalized ServiceYesYes
Name Your Price ToolNoYes

American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance Financial Strength and Reliability

American Family Insurance Financial Strength

American Family Insurance holds a strong financial position with an A (Excellent) rating from AM Best. This rating reflects their strong ability to meet ongoing insurance obligations.

Progressive Car Insurance Financial Strength

Progressive has an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best, indicating exceptional financial stability and a high level of reliability in fulfilling claims obligations.

Financial Strength Comparison Table

Rating AgencyAmerican FamilyProgressive
AM BestA (Excellent)A+ (Superior)

Real-Life Claims Experience in American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance

American Family Insurance Claims Experience

American Family Insurance is highly rated for its efficient and customer-friendly claims process. Customers report quick response times and satisfactory resolutions. Their claims process is streamlined through their mobile app and online portal, making it easy for policyholders to file and track claims.

Progressive Car Insurance Claims Experience

Progressive also offers a robust claims experience, with many customers praising the ease of filing claims through the mobile app and online portal. Progressive’s innovative tools, such as the Concierge Level of Claims Service, provide additional support and convenience for policyholders during the claims process.

Claims Experience Comparison Table

AspectAmerican FamilyProgressive
Ease of FilingExcellentExcellent
Response TimeFastFast
Concierge Claims ServiceNoYes
Customer SatisfactionHighHigh

Testimonials and Reviews on American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance

American Family Insurance Testimonials and Reviews

American Family Insurance consistently receives positive reviews for its customer service, claims handling, and overall satisfaction. Customers often highlight the personalized attention and competitive pricing.

Progressive Car Insurance Testimonials and Reviews

Progressive receives generally positive reviews, with customers appreciating the wide range of coverage options and innovative digital tools. However, some users have noted higher premiums compared to other insurers.

Testimonials Comparison

AspectAmerican FamilyProgressive
Customer ServiceHighly RatedGenerally Positive
PricingCompetitiveHigher than average
Claims ProcessSmooth and EfficientConvenient and Innovative

Roadside Assistance of American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance

American Family Insurance Roadside Assistance

American Family Insurance offers a comprehensive roadside assistance program that includes towing, battery jump-start, flat tire change, lockout service, and fuel delivery. This service can be added to an existing policy for an additional fee.

Progressive Car Insurance Roadside Assistance

Progressive provides an extensive roadside assistance package that includes towing, battery jump-starts, flat tire changes, lockout service, and fuel delivery. Progressive’s roadside assistance is available 24/7 and can be easily accessed through their mobile app.

Roadside Assistance Comparison Table

ServiceAmerican FamilyProgressive
TowingYesYes
Battery Jump-StartYesYes
Flat Tire ChangeYesYes
Lockout ServiceYesYes
Fuel DeliveryYesYes

Interactive Tools of American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance

American Family Insurance Interactive Tools

American Family Insurance offers several interactive tools, including a coverage calculator, an online claims center, and a mobile app for managing policies and filing claims. Their website also features educational resources to help customers make informed decisions.

Progressive Car Insurance Interactive Tools

Progressive excels with its range of interactive tools, such as the Coverage Customizer Tool, which helps customers tailor their insurance coverage to fit their needs. The Progressive app includes features for policy management, claims filing, and accessing roadside assistance.

Interactive Tools Comparison Table

ToolAmerican FamilyProgressive
Coverage CalculatorYesYes
Online Claims CenterYesYes
Mobile AppYesYes
Coverage Customizer ToolNoYes

Conclusion: American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance

Both American Family Insurance and Progressive offer strong car insurance options, each with unique strengths and benefits. American Family Insurance stands out for its personalized customer service, competitive pricing, and efficient claims process. Progressive excels with its innovative tools, comprehensive coverage options, and extensive availability.

Final Recommendation

  • Choose American Family Insurance if you value personalized service, competitive rates, and a strong claims process.
  • Choose Progressive if you want access to a wide range of coverage options, innovative digital tools, and extensive discount programs.

For more detailed insights, visit the official websites of American Family Insurance and Progressive.


This comprehensive guide aims to help you navigate the complexities of choosing between American Family Insurance and Progressive Car Insurance. Whether you prioritize competitive pricing or innovative digital tools, this comparison should aid you in making an informed decision.

Feel free to leave your reviews and experiences with American Family Insurance vs. Progressive Car Insurance in the comments below!


References:

  1. J.D. Power 2023 Auto Insurance Study
  2. NAIC – National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Leave a Comment