Amica Mutual Car Insurance Unbiased Review by Expert 2024

Introduction of Amica Mutual Car Insurance

This post provides a detailed analysis of Amica Mutual Car Insurance, covering pricing, availability, pros and cons, comparisons with other car insurance providers, contact details, regional quotes, testimonials, and reviews.

Amica Mutual Insurance Company, established in 1907, is one of the oldest mutual insurers of automobiles in the United States. Known for its excellent customer service and strong financial stability, Amica Mutual Car Insurance offers a wide range of coverage options tailored to meet the needs of different drivers.

Overview of Amica Mutual Car Insurance

Amica Mutual Car Insurance is designed to provide comprehensive protection for drivers, offering a variety of coverage options including liability, collision, comprehensive, uninsured/underinsured motorist, and personal injury protection (PIP). Additionally, Amica provides several optional coverages and discounts that can help policyholders save on premiums.

Amica Mutual Car Insurance
Amica Mutual Car Insurance

Pricing of Amica Mutual Car Insurance

The cost of Amica Mutual Car Insurance varies based on several factors such as the driver’s age, location, driving history, type of vehicle, and selected coverage options. Here are estimated annual premiums for different coverage levels:

Coverage TypeAnnual Premium (Approx.)
Minimum Liability$450 – $650
Standard Full Coverage$900 – $1,200
Comprehensive Full Coverage$1,200 – $1,500

Availability of Amica Mutual Car Insurance

Amica Mutual Car Insurance is available in all 50 states, ensuring that drivers across the United States can benefit from its comprehensive coverage options. However, the availability of specific discounts and coverage options may vary by state. For detailed information on availability and offerings in your state, it’s best to contact Amica directly or visit their website.

Pros and Cons of Amica Mutual Car Insurance


  • Excellent Customer Service: Amica is renowned for its outstanding customer service and high customer satisfaction ratings.
  • Comprehensive Coverage Options: A wide range of coverage options allows policyholders to customize their insurance to fit their needs.
  • Strong Financial Stability: As a mutual insurance company, Amica is financially stable and highly reliable.
  • Discounts: Numerous discounts are available, such as multi-policy, loyalty, and good driver discounts.
  • Dividend Policies: Policyholders may receive annual dividends, which can help reduce the overall cost of insurance.


  • Higher Premiums: Amica’s premiums can be higher than some competitors, particularly for full coverage options.
  • Limited Online Tools: The online tools and mobile app are not as advanced as those offered by some other insurers.
  • Mixed Reviews on Claims: While many customers praise the claims process, some have reported delays and difficulties.

Comparison of Amica Mutual Car Insurance with Other Car Insurance Providers

When comparing Amica Mutual Car Insurance with other major car insurance providers like GEICO, State Farm, and Allstate, several factors come into play. Below is a comparative analysis:

FeatureAmica MutualGEICOState FarmAllstate
Average Annual Premium$900 – $1,200$800 – $1,100$1,000 – $1,300$1,100 – $1,400
Customer SatisfactionExcellentExcellentVery GoodGood
Coverage OptionsComprehensiveExtensiveExtensiveExtensive
Online ServicesModerateAdvancedAdvancedAdvanced
Financial StabilityStrongStrongStrongStrong

Contact Information of Amica Mutual Car Insurance

For inquiries or to get a quote, customers can reach Amica Mutual Car Insurance through the following channels:

Quotes of Amica Mutual Car Insurance in Different States and Regions

The cost of car insurance can vary significantly by state and region due to factors like state regulations, urban density, and local crime rates. Here are some example quotes for Amica Mutual Car Insurance in different states:

StateMinimum Liability (Annual)Full Coverage (Annual)
New York$650$1,500

Testimonials and Reviews of Amica Mutual Car Insurance

Positive Reviews

  • Rachel M. from Texas: “I’ve been with Amica for over ten years, and their customer service is second to none. Claims are processed quickly and efficiently, and I always feel well taken care of.”
  • John P. from California: “Amica offers great coverage options and competitive rates. I also appreciate the annual dividend payments which help reduce my overall insurance costs.”

Negative Reviews

  • Karen T. from Florida: “I had a few issues with the claims process. It took longer than expected, and communication was lacking. However, the issue was eventually resolved to my satisfaction.”
  • David S. from New York: “My premiums increased significantly after my first year with no major changes to my driving record. It was disappointing, but customer service was helpful in explaining the reasons.”

Addressing Customer Problems of Amica Mutual Car Insurance

Amica Mutual Car Insurance is committed to addressing common customer concerns through continuous improvements:

  1. Claims Processing: Amica is working to streamline its claims processing system to ensure quicker response times and better communication with policyholders.
  2. Premium Stability: The company is reviewing its pricing structure to provide more stable premium rates and avoid unexpected increases.
  3. Online Tools: Amica plans to enhance its online services and mobile app to offer more convenience and self-service options for customers.

Conclusion of Amica Mutual Car Insurance

Amica Mutual Car Insurance offers a solid combination of comprehensive coverage options, excellent customer service, and strong financial stability. While premiums may be higher than some competitors and there is room for improvement in online tools and claims processing times, Amica remains a reliable choice for many drivers across the United States. By continuously addressing customer feedback and enhancing its offerings, Amica aims to maintain its position as a trusted car insurance provider.

For more information or to get a quote, visit Amica Mutual Insurance or call 1-800-242-6422.

Leave a Comment