Shocking Differences Revealed: Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance!

Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance: A Comprehensive Comparison

This guide “Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance” explains pricing, availability, pros and cons, comparisons with other insurers, customer service, Click Here

Choosing the right car insurance can be a daunting task, especially when faced with leading providers like Farmers and Progressive. In this detailed comparison, we’ll explore every aspect of Farmers vs. Progressive car insurance, from pricing and coverage options to customer service and discount programs.

Whether you’re looking for the best rates, exceptional customer service, or comprehensive coverage, this guide will help you make an informed decision.

Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance Pricing and Availability


Farmers Insurance offers competitive pricing, especially for customers with good driving records and multiple policies. The company is known for its flexible payment options and wide range of coverage choices.

  • Average Annual Premium: $1,635
  • Availability: Nationwide (50 states)


Progressive is renowned for its affordability, particularly for drivers with a clean record. With innovative programs like Snapshot, Progressive offers personalized rates based on driving behavior.

  • Average Annual Premium: $1,419
  • Availability: Nationwide (50 states)

Comparison Table: Pricing and Availability

Average Annual Premium$1,635$1,419
States Available5050
Primary MarketsNationwideNationwide

Coverage Options in Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance


Farmers offers a broad spectrum of coverage options, including standard liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage, as well as unique options like new car replacement and accident forgiveness.


Progressive provides a variety of coverage options, including liability, collision, comprehensive, and unique features such as custom parts and equipment coverage, and rideshare coverage for drivers.

Comparison Table: Coverage Options

Coverage TypeFarmersProgressive
Personal Injury ProtectionYesYes
New Car ReplacementYesNo
Accident ForgivenessYesYes
Rideshare Driver CoverageNoYes
Custom Parts & EquipmentNoYes

Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance Pros and Cons



  • Comprehensive coverage options
  • Excellent customer service
  • Strong financial stability
  • Numerous discounts available


  • Higher premiums for high-risk drivers
  • Some coverage options are more expensive



  • Affordable rates
  • Innovative usage-based discounts
  • Wide range of coverage options
  • Robust online tools and mobile app


  • Customer service can be inconsistent
  • Higher rates for drivers with poor credit

Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance Customer Service and Financial Strength


Farmers is known for its strong customer service, with personalized support from local agents. Financially, Farmers holds a robust rating from A.M. Best, ensuring reliability and trustworthiness.


Progressive offers comprehensive customer support through their website, mobile app, and customer service hotline. Their financial strength is affirmed by a high rating from A.M. Best.

Comparison Table: Customer Service and Financial Strength

Customer Service Rating4.5/54.3/5
Financial Strength RatingAA+
Helpline Number1-888-327-63351-800-776-4737
Mobile AppYesYes

Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance Real-Life Claims Experience


Farmers is praised for its smooth and efficient claims process. Policyholders often highlight the responsiveness of agents and the ease of filing a claim online or through the mobile app.


Progressive also scores well in terms of claims handling, with many customers appreciating the straightforward process and helpful representatives. However, some have reported delays in settlement.

Testimonials and Reviews


  • “Farmers made my claims experience easy and stress-free. Their customer service is top-notch.” – Sarah J.
  • “I had a great experience with Farmers during my recent claim. The process was quick and hassle-free.” – Mike D.


  • “Progressive handled my claim efficiently. The representatives were helpful and understanding.” – Lisa K.
  • “The claims process was smooth, but it took a bit longer than expected to get my settlement.” – John W.

Discount Programs of Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance


Farmers offers a variety of discounts, including multi-policy, good student, anti-theft, and safe driver discounts. Their Signal app provides usage-based discounts for safe driving.


Progressive provides numerous discounts such as multi-policy, good student, and safe driver discounts. Their Snapshot program offers personalized rates based on driving behavior.

Comparison Table: Discount Programs

Discount TypeFarmersProgressive
Good StudentYesYes
Anti-Theft DeviceYesYes
Safe DriverYesYes
Usage-Based (Signal)YesNo
Snapshot Usage-BasedNoYes

Customer Service Innovations of Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance


Farmers leverages technology to enhance customer service, offering a robust mobile app for policy management, claims filing, and accessing roadside assistance. Their customer portal provides easy access to all policy details.


Progressive is known for its innovative use of technology in customer service. Their mobile app includes features like policy management, claims tracking, and roadside assistance. The Name Your Price tool allows customers to tailor policies to their budgets.

Financial Strength and Reliability


Farmers boasts solid financial strength, with an A rating from A.M. Best, indicating a strong ability to meet policyholder obligations.


Progressive holds an A+ rating from A.M. Best, reflecting superior financial stability and reliability, providing peace of mind to policyholders.

Real-Life Claims Experience


Farmers’ claims experience is generally positive, with many customers praising the efficiency and helpfulness of their claims representatives. However, some have noted occasional delays in settlements.


Progressive’s claims process is highly rated, particularly for the ease of use through their mobile app and online platform. Their extensive network of agents ensures personalized support during the claims process.

Interactive Tools


Farmers offers a variety of online tools, including quote calculators, coverage options comparisons, and a user-friendly mobile app for managing policies and filing claims.


Progressive’s interactive tools are top-notch, with their mobile app and website providing comprehensive features such as virtual assistance, claims tracking, and the Name Your Price tool.

Coverage and Pricing by State

Car insurance rates and coverage options can vary significantly by state. Below is a comparative look at how Farmers and Progressive perform in several key states.


  • Farmers: Competitive rates, strong coverage options.
  • Progressive: Affordable rates, extensive discount programs.


  • Farmers: Moderate rates, comprehensive coverage options.
  • Progressive: Competitive rates, wide availability.


  • Farmers: Moderate rates, good coverage options.
  • Progressive: Competitive rates, comprehensive coverage.

Comparison Table: Coverage and Pricing by State


Insurer Rates by Violation

Insurance rates can vary based on driving violations. Here’s a look at how rates change with common violations for both insurers.


  • Speeding Ticket: 18% increase
  • DUI: 45% increase
  • Accident: 28% increase


  • Speeding Ticket: 20% increase
  • DUI: 50% increase
  • Accident: 30% increase

Comparison Table: Insurer Rates by Violation

Speeding Ticket18% increase20% increase
DUI45% increase50% increase
Accident28% increase30% increase

Insurer Rates by Age


  • Young Drivers (Under 25): Higher rates due to risk.
  • Middle-Aged Drivers (25-55): Lower rates with a good driving record.
  • Senior Drivers (55+): Moderate rates, with potential discounts.


  • Young Drivers (Under 25): Competitive rates with student discounts.
  • Middle-Aged Drivers (25-55): Very competitive rates.
  • Senior Drivers (55+): Competitive rates with defensive driving discounts.

Comparison Table: Insurer Rates by Age

| Age Group | Farmers | Progressive |

| Under 25 | High | Competitive |
| 25-55 | Lower | Very Competitive |
| 55+ | Moderate | Competitive |

Roadside Assistance


Farmers offers comprehensive roadside assistance, including towing, lockout services, and emergency roadside repairs, accessible through their mobile app.


Progressive provides roadside assistance as an add-on to their policies. Services include towing, battery jump-starts, and lockout assistance.

Customer Satisfaction Scores

According to the latest J.D. Power Auto Insurance Study, customer satisfaction scores for both insurers are as follows:

  • Farmers: 825/1000
  • Progressive: 830/1000

Asking Users to Leave Reviews

Your feedback is invaluable! If you’ve had an experience with Farmers or Progressive, please leave a review below to help others make an informed decision.

Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance Conclusion: Which Company is Best?

Choosing between Farmers and Progressive largely depends on your specific needs and circumstances. Progressive generally offers more competitive rates and a wider range of discounts, making it an excellent choice for most drivers. Farmers, however, excels in providing unique coverage options and personalized customer service.

Ultimately, it’s crucial to compare quotes from both insurers and consider your individual requirements. Use their online tools to get a personalized quote and ensure you’re getting the best coverage at the best price.

Reference Links of Farmers vs. Progressive Car Insurance

  1. J.D. Power Auto Insurance Study
  2. National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC)

By understanding the detailed differences between Farmers and Progressive, you can make an informed decision and choose the car insurance that best fits your needs.

Leave a Comment