Is PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance the Ultimate Car Insurance for You? Find Out Now!

Table of Contents

PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance: Comprehensive Comparison

Introduction of PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance

This guide “PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance” explains pricing, availability, pros and cons, comparisons with other insurers, customer service, Click Here

Choosing the right car insurance can be a daunting task with so many options available. In this post, we will compare “PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance” to help you make an informed decision. We’ll cover pricing, availability, pros and cons, comparisons with other car insurance providers, helpline numbers, and more.

Pricing of PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance

Average Premiums

Understanding the cost of car insurance is crucial for every driver. Below, we present the average premiums for PEMCO and Progressive across different states and regions.

StatePEMCO (Annual)Progressive (Annual)

Source: J.D. Power and NAIC

Coverage Options

Both PEMCO and Progressive offer a variety of coverage options to suit different needs.

Coverage TypePEMCOProgressive
Liability CoverageYesYes
Collision CoverageYesYes
Comprehensive CoverageYesYes
Personal Injury ProtectionYesYes
Uninsured/Underinsured MotoristYesYes
Medical PaymentsYesYes

Availability of PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance

National Reach

PEMCO primarily serves the Pacific Northwest, particularly Washington and Oregon, while Progressive provides car insurance across the United States. Availability and pricing may vary based on state regulations.

Contact Information

  • PEMCO Customer Service: 1-800-467-3626
  • Progressive Customer Service: 1-800-776-4737

PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance Pros and Cons



  • Strong customer satisfaction in the Pacific Northwest.
  • Competitive rates for safe drivers.
  • Focus on community and local events.


  • Limited geographic availability.
  • Fewer digital tools compared to larger insurers.



  • Nationwide availability.
  • Extensive discount programs.
  • Innovative digital tools and mobile app.


  • Higher rates for drivers with violations.
  • Mixed reviews on customer service.

Comparison of PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance with Other Car Insurances

When comparing “PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance” to other providers, it’s essential to consider customer satisfaction, financial strength, and claims handling.

Customer Satisfaction Scores

According to J.D. Power:

  • PEMCO: 4.5/5
  • Progressive: 3.5/5

Financial Strength Ratings

  • PEMCO: A- (A.M. Best)
  • Progressive: A+ (A.M. Best)

Discount Programs of PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance

PEMCO Discounts

  • Safe Driver
  • Multi-Policy
  • Accident-Free
  • Good Student

Progressive Discounts

  • Multi-Policy
  • Snapshot (usage-based)
  • Good Student
  • Continuous Insurance

Discount Comparison

Discount TypePEMCOProgressive
Good DriverYesYes
Safe VehicleYesYes

Roadside Assistance of PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance

Both providers offer roadside assistance services, which can be a lifesaver in emergencies.

PEMCO Roadside Assistance

  • Towing
  • Flat tire change
  • Battery jump-start

Progressive Roadside Assistance

  • Towing
  • Fuel delivery
  • Lockout services

PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance Customer Satisfaction and Testimonials

PEMCO Reviews

Customers generally praise PEMCO for its excellent customer service and community involvement. The focus on local events and personalized service is a significant draw for many policyholders.

PEMCO Customer Testimonial:

“PEMCO’s customer service is top-notch, and their rates are competitive for safe drivers. I love their community-focused approach!” – Emily R.

Progressive Reviews

Progressive receives mixed reviews, with many customers appreciating the wide range of discounts and digital tools, but some expressing frustration with customer service and claims handling.

Progressive Customer Testimonial:

“Progressive’s rates are competitive, and their Snapshot program saved me a lot of money. However, I’ve had mixed experiences with their customer service.” – Mark S.

PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance Interactive Tools and Innovations


  • Online Quotes: Quick and easy online quote process.
  • Local Focus: Community events and local engagement.


  • Mobile App: Comprehensive app with Snapshot, Progressive’s telematics program.
  • Name Your Price Tool: Allows customers to customize their policy based on their budget.

Real-Life Claims Experience in PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance

PEMCO Claims Experience

Many policyholders report smooth and efficient claims processing with PEMCO, particularly appreciating their local focus and personalized service.

Progressive Claims Experience

Progressive’s claims experience is mixed, with some customers praising quick resolution, while others report delays and communication issues.

PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance Financial Strength and Reliability

Both PEMCO and Progressive boast strong financial ratings, ensuring they can handle large volumes of claims and provide reliable service.

PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance INSURER RATES BY VIOLATION

Include how each company handles rate increases for common violations.

Violation TypePEMCO (% Increase)Progressive (% Increase)
Speeding Ticket15%22%
At-Fault Accident30%40%

PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance Rates by Age Group

Provide detailed rate comparisons for different age groups.

Age GroupPEMCO (Annual)Progressive (Annual)

Common Customer Problems and Solutions of PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance

Address common issues customers face with both companies and how they can resolve them.

Common Issues with PEMCO:

  • Limited Availability: PEMCO primarily serves Washington and Oregon. If you move out of these states, you may need to switch providers.
  • Digital Tools: PEMCO offers fewer digital tools compared to larger insurers. Using their online resources and contacting customer service can help navigate this.

Common Issues with Progressive:

  • Claims Processing Delays: Use the online claims tracking tool and maintain regular communication with your claims representative.
  • Rate Increases: Maintain a clean driving record and utilize discount programs like Snapshot to potentially lower rates.

Specific Coverage Add-Ons

Detail additional coverage options that each provider offers, such as:

  • PEMCO: New Car Replacement, Custom Parts and Equipment Coverage.
  • Progressive: Rideshare Insurance, Pet Injury Coverage.

Mobile App and Online Tools Comparison

Highlight the key features of each company’s mobile app and online tools.

FeaturePEMCO AppProgressive App
Policy ManagementYesYes
Claims FilingYesYes
Digital ID CardsYesYes
Telematics ProgramNoYes (Snapshot)
Roadside Assistance AccessYesYes
Billing and PaymentsYesYes

Rate Comparison by Credit Level

Include how each company handles rates based on credit scores.

Credit LevelPEMCO (Annual)Progressive (Annual)

Insurance Rates by Driving Habits

Compare rates for various driving habits, such as annual mileage.

Annual MileagePEMCO (Annual)Progressive (Annual)
Under 6,000 miles$1,200$1,400
6,000 – 12,000 miles$1,400$1,600
Over 12,000 miles$1,600$1,800

Anti-Theft and Safety Discounts

Provide information on specific discounts available for anti-theft and safety features.

Discount TypePEMCOProgressive
Anti-Theft DeviceYesYes
Safety FeaturesYesYes
Defensive Driving CourseYesYes

Real-Life Claims Experience Testimonials

Include more real customer testimonials from various platforms to give readers a personal perspective.

PEMCO Customer Testimonial:

“After my accident, PEMCO was incredibly supportive and quick with the claims process. Their local approach made me feel valued as a customer.” – Sarah L.

Progressive Customer Testimonial:

“Progressive’s Snapshot program has been great for saving money. My only complaint is that their customer service could be more responsive.” – David K.

Common Customer Problems and Solutions

Expand on common issues and provide more detailed solutions.

Common Issues with PEMCO:

  • Limited Coverage Area: For those who frequently move or travel outside Washington and Oregon, consider a backup insurance provider or inquire about PEMCO’s partner networks.
  • Digital Services: Leverage PEMCO’s strong customer service team for assistance when digital tools are lacking.

Common Issues with Progressive:

  • Customer Service Response Time: Use the online chat feature for quicker responses and keep detailed records of communications.
  • Telematics Program Data Usage: Ensure you understand how Snapshot data is used to calculate discounts and adjust your driving habits accordingly.

Encouraging Reader Engagement

Encourage readers to leave their own reviews and experiences with PEMCO and Progressive.

“We value your feedback! Please share your experiences with PEMCO or Progressive car insurance in the comments below to help others in our community.”

Conclusion from PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance

Choosing between PEMCO and Progressive car insurance depends on your specific needs and circumstances. If you live in the Pacific Northwest and value local, personalized

service, PEMCO may be the right choice. Conversely, if you value a wide range of discounts, nationwide availability, and advanced digital tools, Progressive might be better suited for you. Both companies are reputable and provide comprehensive coverage options.

References from PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance

This comprehensive comparison of “PEMCO vs. Progressive Car Insurance” aims to provide you with all the necessary information to make an informed decision. Please share your experiences and leave reviews to help others in the community.

Leave a Comment