Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance in 2024

This guide delves deep into Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance, exploring pricing, availability, pros and cons, comparisons with competitors, and how they address customer concerns.

Finding the right car insurance can feel like navigating a stormy sea. Plymouth Rock Assurance, established in 1982, aims to provide a smooth journey with their auto insurance solutions.

Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance
Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance

Charting Your Course: Availability of Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance

Unlike some national giants, Plymouth Rock Assurance focuses on specific territories. Their car insurance is currently available in six states:

New HampshireYes
New JerseyYes
New YorkYes

How Much Will It Cost? Exploring Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance

Providing exact quotes for Plymouth Rock Assurance is difficult upfront. Rates depend on various factors like driving record, location, vehicle type, and chosen coverage. However, Plymouth Rock generally caters to drivers with clean records and higher-value vehicles, so premiums might be on the higher side compared to budget insurers.

Getting a Quote for Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance: Setting Sail for Coverage

Plymouth Rock Assurance works through a network of independent agents. Here’s how to obtain a quote:

  1. Find an Agent: Visit Plymouth Rock’s website ( and use their agent locator tool.
  2. Contact the Agent: Reach out to your chosen agent via phone, email, or visit their office.
  3. Provide Details: The agent will ask for information like your driving record, vehicle details, and desired coverage.
  4. Receive Quote: The agent will provide quotes from Plymouth Rock and potentially compare them with other insurers.

What’s on the Plymouth Rock Menu? Coverage Options Offered

Plymouth Rock Assurance offers a comprehensive range of auto insurance coverages to safeguard your journey:

Coverage TypeDescription
Liability CoverageProtects you financially if you cause an accident and injure someone or damage their property.
Collision CoveragePays for repairs to your vehicle if you collide with another object.
Comprehensive CoverageCovers damage to your car from non-collision events like theft, vandalism, fire, or weather.
Medical PaymentsProvides medical coverage for you and your passengers in case of injuries sustained in an accident, regardless of fault.
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist CoverageProtects you if the driver who caused the accident has no insurance or not enough to cover the damages.
Roadside AssistanceOffers 24/7 assistance for services like towing, flat tire changes, jumpstarts, and lockout assistance (availability might vary by plan).
Additional CoveragesPlymouth Rock also provides optional coverages like accident forgiveness, rental car reimbursement, and OEM parts coverage for repairs using genuine parts.

Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance: Weighing the Anchor (Pros and Cons)


  • Strong Financial Stability: A solid financial rating ensures they can meet your claims in case of an accident.
  • Focus on Customer Service: Plymouth Rock prides itself on personalized service through its network of independent agents.
  • Specialized Coverage Options: Features like OEM parts coverage cater to drivers concerned about maintaining their vehicle’s value.
  • Potential Discounts: Discounts are offered for bundling car insurance with homeowners insurance, having a clean driving record, and taking defensive driving courses.
  • Unique Perks: Plymouth Rock offers benefits like “Get Home Safe®” which reimburses for taxi rides home under certain circumstances.


  • Limited Availability: Plymouth Rock’s coverage is restricted to six states.
  • Potentially Higher Rates: Premiums might be on the higher side compared to budget insurers.
  • Reliance on Independent Agents: Getting quotes requires contacting an agent, which can be less convenient than online options.
  • Customer Concerns: Some customers have reported issues with claim processing times and communication gaps.

Addressing Rough Waters: How Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance Handles Customer Concerns

While some customers have encountered challenges, Plymouth Rock acknowledges these concerns and is taking steps to improve:

  • Streamlined Processes: They’re reportedly working on streamlining claim processing procedures for faster resolutions.
  • Enhanced Communication: Efforts are underway to improve communication and keep customers informed throughout the claims process.
  • Investing in Technology: Plymouth Rock might be investing in technology to improve the online experience and potentially offer online quote options in the future.

How to Navigate the Seas Smoothly: Tips for Dealing with Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance

  • Actively Communicate: Don’t hesitate to reach out to your agent or Plymouth Rock’s customer service.
  • Actively Communicate: Don’t hesitate to reach out to your agent or Plymouth Rock’s customer service (855-993-4470) if you have any questions or concerns during the claims process.Utilize Available Tools: While their online features might be limited currently, explore their website for policy management tools (if available) and keep an eye out for potential future developments in online account management or quote options.Stay Informed: Monitor Plymouth Rock’s website and communication channels for updates regarding policy changes, claim process improvements, and their efforts in addressing customer concerns.

Comparing Courses: Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance vs. The Competition

Here’s a table comparing Plymouth Rock Assurance with two other major car insurance providers:

FeaturePlymouth Rock AssuranceGeicoProgressive
Availability6 states (CT, MA, NH, NJ, NY, PA)NationwideNationwide
Target CustomerClean record, high-value vehiclesBudget-conscious driversDiverse range of drivers
Customer ServiceIndependent agentsDirect and agent optionsDirect and agent options
Potential DiscountsBundling, clean driving record, defensive driving courses, accident forgivenessBundling, good student, military, multi-carBundling, good student, safe driver, usage-based programs
Recent DevelopmentsFocus on improving claim processing and communicationNo major changes reportedNo major changes reported
Unique PerksGet Home Safe® (taxi reimbursement)NoneNone

Who Should Cast Off with Plymouth Rock Assurance Car Insurance?

Plymouth Rock might be a good fit for you if:

  • You reside in one of their six service states and have a clean driving record.
  • You own a high-value vehicle and prioritize specialized coverage options like OEM parts.
  • You value personalized service from a local agent who can guide you through your insurance needs.
  • You appreciate unique perks like “Get Home Safe®” offered by Plymouth Rock.

Alternative Harbors: Exploring Other Options

If you don’t live in a state serviced by Plymouth Rock or prioritize budget-friendly rates and online convenience, consider these alternatives:

  • National Carriers: Geico, Progressive, and State Farm offer nationwide coverage, various online tools for quotes and policy management, and cater to a wider range of driver profiles.
  • Regional Carriers: Depending on your location, regional insurance companies might offer competitive rates, personalized service, and cater to specific needs within your state.

Choosing the Right Course: Making an Informed Decision

By carefully considering your driving record, vehicle value, desired coverage options, budget, and location, you can compare quotes from multiple insurers, including Plymouth Rock Assurance. This will help you select the car insurance that best navigates your needs and keeps you financially secure on the road.

Additional Tips for a Smooth Voyage

  • Read Online Reviews: Customer reviews can offer valuable insights into real-life experiences with Plymouth Rock’s customer service and claims handling.
  • Consider Usage-Based Insurance: If you’re a low-mileage driver, explore usage-based insurance options offered by some providers, which can potentially lead to lower rates.
  • Reevaluate Regularly: Don’t settle for the first quote you receive. Reassess your insurance needs periodically and compare rates to ensure you’re getting the best possible coverage at a competitive price.

By following these tips and leveraging the information provided, you can confidently navigate the car insurance landscape and find the coverage that sets sail for a smooth and secure journey on the road.

Leave a Comment